The recent round of elections has witnessed a decline in voter turnout. Much has been made of the possible causes, ranging from the increase in high-velocity political mudslinging, through to election fatigue or general ambivalence toward the political menu in terms of leaders and policies.
Whereas the diagnosis may be political disconnectedness, any analysis of possible causes should include a broader look at how Canadians trust their government. To that end, Nanos commissioned some original research on how much Canadians trust government. Canadians were asked to rate their trust scores from 1 to 10, where 1 was no trust at all and 10 was complete trust, on a series of elements including procuring contracts, enforcing regulations, working in the public interest and appointing non-elected public officials.
Canadians give their governments, both provincial and federal, poor or failing grades on almost all the measures. Looking across all the data, on any given trust score, only between seven and fourteen percent of Canadians rate their government with a good trust score of 8, 9 or 10 on a 10-point scale.
In the province of Quebec, one moves from black to pitch black, with lower provincial trust scores compared to other regions. The fact remains, however, that Quebecers trust their provincial government only marginally less compared to Canadians in other parts of Canada. It is not the huge chasm one might expect.
Among Canadians as a whole, trust scores for their governments were weak, but comparatively stronger on factors such as enforcement of government regulations and working in the public interest. However, the question remains as to whether a score of about 5 out of 10 for enforcing government regulations should be considered acceptable or good. Probably not.
One must remember, however, that this is a benchmark. Tracking changes over time will be the true benefit of the research: is trust on the increase or is it on the decline?
If trust in government is one of the canaries in the coal mine in terms of voter engagement, this is one that clearly merits closer scrutiny.
Nik Nanos is the President of Nanos Research, a research associate professor at the State University of New York at Buffalo and the official pollster for CTV News and The Globe and Mail.